How to tell whether an app can send your data anywhere
Most apps you install can reach the internet, and most of the time that’s fine: a weather app needs the forecast. The trouble is the apps that don’t need it for their job but still send data somewhere, and you can’t tell from the screen.
Some findings from people who have looked:
- Budgeting apps. In 2023, Incogni read the Google Play listings of 20 popular Android budgeting apps and found that 12 of them said they share at least some data with third parties.
- Mental health and prayer apps. In May 2022, Mozilla’s *Privacy Not Included guide reviewed 32 of them and gave 28 its privacy warning label. Mozilla called them “worse than any other product category” its researchers had reviewed in six years.
- Flashlight apps. In 2019, Avast looked at 937 flashlight apps on Google Play. They asked for 25 permissions on average, and some for as many as 77, to turn a light on and off.
You can’t audit an app yourself, but you can learn a lot in five minutes. Here’s what to check on Android.
1. Read the Data safety section
On an app’s Google Play page there’s a Data safety section, and See details opens all of it. The developer says there what data the app collects (takes off your phone), what it shares with third parties, whether that data is encrypted in transit, and whether you can ask for it to be deleted.
Read the “shared” part first. Then ask whether each item makes sense for what the app does. A budgeting app collecting your transactions may be the point; sharing your location with advertisers isn’t.
One caution: these answers are written by the developer. Google’s own help page says the section is based on “information declared by app developers”, and that its reviews don’t verify that what’s declared is accurate or complete. Incogni’s study above was based on exactly these declarations, so they’re useful, but they aren’t proof.
2. Look at the permissions list
The permissions an app declares are a record of what it can do, not what it says it does. On Google Play, open About this app and scroll down; near the bottom, the app’s details include its full permissions list. The layout of that page moves around from time to time, so you may need to look for it.
The one to look for is have full network access. That’s Android’s name for the internet permission, and an app needs it to send anything over Wi-Fi or mobile data. Almost every app has it, and having it doesn’t mean an app is misbehaving. But if an app that has no reason to go online (a flashlight, a calculator, a notes app that doesn’t sync) has it, it’s fair to ask why.
Android’s own Settings won’t show you this one. App info → Permissions lists the permissions you can switch on and off, such as the camera, location and contacts. Network access isn’t one of them on most phones, so the store’s list is the place to see it.
3. Check how much data it has used
In App info, look for Mobile data or Mobile data & Wi-Fi (the name varies by phone). It shows how much data the app has used, sometimes split into foreground and background. Some phones also show Wi-Fi use per app under the network settings.
An offline notes app that has used hundreds of megabytes is talking to something. A number close to zero doesn’t prove much on its own, but a large one is worth a question.
4. Look it up on Exodus Privacy
Exodus Privacy, run by a French non-profit, analyses Android apps and lists the trackers built into them: software meant to collect data about you or how you use the app. Search by the app’s name or paste its Google Play link. Trackers for analytics and ads are common, and the report names them.
5. Notice the small signs
- It asks you to sign up before it’s done anything. An account means your data has somewhere to go. Sometimes that’s needed, for sync. Often it isn’t. Our list of apps that work without an account has a quick test with aeroplane mode.
- It shows ads. Ads are fetched from the internet, and ad networks usually learn something about you in return.
- It asks for a permission at an odd moment. A notes app asking for your location or contacts deserves a “Not now”.
How Shadowkit answers these
We make Shadowkit, so here are its answers, for you to check:
- No full network access. Shadowkit’s Android app doesn’t have the internet permission, so it has no way to send your data anywhere. We explain why, and what you give up, in why Shadowkit has no account.
- The permissions it does have are listed in our privacy policy, each with what it’s for. One that can look alarming is view network connections: the Data skill uses it to tell whether you’re on Wi-Fi or mobile data. It reads the connection’s type, and it can’t send anything.
- No trackers, ads or analytics, and no account.
- What leaves the phone is what you send. A backup file goes where you save it, and a note or a split goes to whoever you share it with, through your phone’s own share sheet.
On iPhone there’s no internet permission to check, so these steps are Android’s. Whatever app you use, the permissions list is the closest thing to a fact you can read before you install.